We took a trip to Cologne last weekend, doing all the tourist things like visiting the cathedral, the Roman-German Museum, the Chocolate Museum, and of course, drinking lots of Kölsch.
Kölsch is a bit of a hybrid beer — brewed with ale yeast, fermented a little cooler than most ales, and then cold-aged like lager. I think the first time I had it was French Broad’s Gateway Kolsch, which I had on my first trip to Asheville, in 2010. And since then, I’ve only seen it a few times. We looked for bottled Kölsch, and were only able to find one that was actually from Cologne.
Luckily, I found the incomparable European Beer Guide page on Cologne, and was able to make a good list of which ones I wanted to try and where to find them. Most pubs in Cologne serve just one brand of beer (even if they aren’t brewery-owned). But Cologne is pretty small, and there are pubs all over. They are mostly family-friendly, so it was easy to work in quite a few in a weekend of seeing the sights with the kids. Since Kölsch is supposed to be drunk cold, it’s typically served in small, skinny glasses (20cl, about 7 oz.), carried around in a distinctive tray for speedy service. So it all adds up to a pretty pleasant pub crawl town.
My favorite Kölsch is probably Früh Kölsch. We had a nice, sausage-heavy lunch, tempered with tender white asparagus and sauerkraut, at Früh’s pub Früh am Dom. The pub is just off the cathedral square, and looks like a normal scale pub from the front, but expands a long way back and downstairs. It’s nice and cozy throughout. Their Kölsch is very mild and clean, with just a little sweetness and not much hop bitterness. For a sweeter version, they serve Radler, a shandy made with their Kölsch and lemon soda. I didn’t like this quite as much as the straight Kölsch, but it was very light and refreshing, with some bitter lemon peel flavor to keep it from being sickly sweet. It was pleasant but not hot in mid-May, but I can imagine the Radler being very nice when summer starts heating up.
A close runner-up would be Pfaffen Kölsch. Their bar is in the Heumarkt square, just around the corner from our hotel. I went there twice, but never actually made it inside, since there was a crowd out front enjoying the nice weather at all hours. The service was very quick, with a waiter coming and going with the typical tray of tall, skinny glasses at all times. Their Kölsch is pretty malty, a little reedy, and nicely light and refreshing.
Lower on my list is Mühlen Kölsch from Malzmühle. You can see their pub from Pfaffen, at the other end of the Heumarkt. But a couple of roads and a tram station lie in the way, making it a bit of a trek at the best of times. There was also a Pirate Party rally going on in the square, and a cluster of cops on motorcycles, making it even harder than usual to get through the traffic. Once inside, the pub was nice enough, though not as cozy as Früh am Dom. Though it was hard to get to, it was very busy — in fact, it was the only place we had trouble getting a table. I found their Kölsch a little disappointing — definitely hoppier than most, dry, and astringent.
I also liked Gilden Kölsch more than average. Their pub on the Heumarkt was much more modern and spacious than most, but still ran back from the front quite a bit, and into the basement. Unlike most of pubs we went to, the only antique thing in Gilden was the barrel of Kölsch on the bar. Their Kölsch is mild, with a bit of herbal hoppiness.
My least favorite Kölsch was definitely Gaffel Kölsch. Quite a few of the restaurants had Gaffel banners, and I had a large glass (40cl, but still the same shape) with dinner, and found it bland and lagery. I also didn’t care for Peters Kölsch, which was very dry and hoppy (and now contract brewed). Though it probably doesn’t help that they were badly understaffed and it took me 10 minutes to get a glass.
We also had some non-Kölsch beers — some Franziskaner Hefeweizen on the train, and a very nice Paulaner Kristalweizen (I think the first kristalweizen I’ve had) with lunch. Since it’s filtered hefeweizen, it was pretty much the same as a hef, but without the cloudiness or yeasty character. It went perfectly with juicy grilled chicken tacos. And at the Chocolate Museum, we picked up a bottle of Strubbe Chocolat – kind of an amber ale with a definite chocolate flavor. Not something I’d go out of my way for, but an interesting novelty beer.






